CAPITAL DISPATCH

The SEC Tells Asset Managers to Stop Comparing Notes

A report on Climate Action 100+ warns that coordinated votes and publicity campaigns can make big investors a group in the eyes of the law.

Illustration: two chess kings separated by a gold line

The Securities and Exchange Commission has warned asset managers that coordinating on proxy fights and pressure campaigns can make them a "group" under securities law, with the stricter ownership disclosure that comes with it.

The warning came in a Section 21(a) Report of Investigation issued Oct. 7 on Climate Action 100+ and the 2021 proxy fight at ExxonMobil. The SEC brought no enforcement action and made no findings of violations. But it flagged coordinated voting in director elections, agreed evaluation frameworks and pressure campaigns, including negative publicity, as conduct that can point to group formation.

Public statements disclaiming coordination are not enough on their own, the report says, if a manager's practices don't match its policies. It also questions whether managers taking part in such campaigns still qualify for the lighter Schedule 13G filing regime, with particular scrutiny for index funds.

Source: Sullivan & Cromwell summary of the SEC report.